The cheapest round trip option we've found recently is to Rome for $407 and to Milan for $786.
All Cities
Milan
Rome
05 Jul (Fri) - 27 Jul (Sat)05 Jul (Fri) + nights
20:55
JFK
11h 45m
1 stop
08:40
LIN
09:20
LIN
14h 0m
1 stop
23:20
JFK
$786
Found 3 days ago
03 Jun (Mon) - 15 Jun (Sat)03 Jun (Mon) + nights
15:20
JFK
20h 5m
1 stop
11:25
FCO
13:40
FCO
23h 10m
1 stop
12:50
JFK
$407
Found an hour ago
Direct flights to Italy
There are 10 airlines that fly directly to Italy: Finnair, Air France, Alitalia, Emirates, British Airways, American Airlines, Delta Air Lines, Iberia, KLM, Neos. Most airlines that have direct connections are departing from John F. Kennedy International Airport. Most airlines arrive to Leonardo da Vinci-Fiumicino Airport, Milan-Malpensa Airport, Venice Marco Polo Airport. Most flights depart on Monday, Tuesday.